Feedback on the first draft of the Bellagio Principles on Valuing Water (Principles)

Are the principles sufficiently actionable?

Back to overview

Comments

Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0
Alexandra 1 month ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 2 months ago

Again, the principles are concise and easy to understand but do not establish guidelines for implementation and/or means to put into action.

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 3 months ago

No, but the principles can serve as a basis for developing actions, and this should be made more explicit. This could be stated in a new principle (another Principle #2) stating that decisions about water policies, programs, or initiatives should be desi

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 3 months ago

Yes

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 3 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 3 months ago

Yes, but the question is the ownership. who should put these principles into action or safeguard that they are being put into action?

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 4 months ago

Truly they are.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 4 months ago

I don't know. They are not new and action has not been taken adequately. So let's say this document is a basis for political leadership, to get to a transition on water management and use.

  0     0
martina Zupan 4 months ago

not on the ground level

  0     0
Sutardi 4 months ago

no, need more practical guidance extracting from various type of cases

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 4 months ago

YES. We should be aware of financing, as always.

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 4 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 4 months ago

no

  0     0