Feedback on the first draft of the Bellagio Principles on Valuing Water (Principles)

Do the principles represent a clear storyline? If not, what is missing?

Back to overview

Comments

Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Mohd Adnan bin Mohd Nor 10 months ago

Principle No 4: "Advocacy" rather than merely "awareness" would be more affirmative. Principle 2 and 4 Missing: The need to provide formal platforms for public participation

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Mohd Adnan bin Mohd Nor 10 months ago

Principle No 4: "Advocacy" rather than merely "awareness" would be more affirmative. Principle 2 and 4 Missing: The need to provide formal platforms for public participation

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Mohd Adnan bin Mohd Nor 10 months ago

Principle No 4: "Advocacy" rather than merely "awareness" would be more affirmative. Principle 2 and 4 Missing: The need to provide formal platforms for public participation

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Mohd Adnan bin Mohd Nor 10 months ago

Principle No 4: "Advocacy" rather than merely "awareness" would be more affirmative. Principle 2 and 4 Missing: The need to provide formal platforms for public participation

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Mohd Adnan bin Mohd Nor 10 months ago

Principle No 4: "Advocacy" rather than merely "awareness" would be more affirmative. Principle 2 and 4 Missing: The need to provide formal platforms for public participation

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
Alexandra 7 months ago

yes

  0     0
José Antonio Gutiérrez Gnecchi 8 months ago

Although it is implied, there is little mention about the ever increasing level of contamination by geogenic and anthropogenic sources. For instance, the increasing amount of emerging contaminants is a threat to ensure access to safe water sources and can

  0     0
FELICIA IRIMA NGAJI-USIBE 9 months ago

Represent a clear story line

  0     0
David Groenfeldt 9 months ago

Two missing elements: (1) In my view there needs to be a new statement, probably as the 2nd principle, that links the Bellagio Principles with UN-sanctioned principles of human rights, where these are reasonably connected to water. These include the rig

  0     0
John Waweru Gakunga 9 months ago

They do

  0     0
JOHN WAWERU 9 months ago

YES

  0     0
Giacomo Galli 9 months ago

Yes storyline is clear. One element that needs elaboration is that the current crises in water are not 'somehow appearing', but the results of certain (political/economical/etc.) choices. The need to take different values into account comes forth from the

  0     0
Shahjahan Bhatti 10 months ago

Using satellite images to protect projects is required.

  0     0
D. Hirsch 10 months ago

Women's role and perspective is missing.

  0     0
Mohd Adnan bin Mohd Nor 10 months ago

Principle No 4: "Advocacy" rather than merely "awareness" would be more affirmative. Principle 2 and 4 Missing: The need to provide formal platforms for public participation

  0     0
martina Zupan 10 months ago

maybe the role of civil society is not accented enough

  0     0
Sutardi 10 months ago

Not, need an example of real life probems

  0     0
Guillermo Saavedra 10 months ago

YES

  0     0
Sanjay Banka 10 months ago

Yes

  0     0
Trudi Schifter 10 months ago

no comment

  0     0
shailendra Tiwari 3 months ago

yes

  0     0
Arturo Constante 3 months ago

No clearly identified in terms of resource availability vs accessibility, must be for past, present and future

  0     0